The U.S. Senate on Tuesday confirmed President Donald Trump’s nominee to lead the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), marking a pivotal moment in the administration’s broader effort to clean house after years of public health mismanagement and pandemic-era overreach.
Susan Monarez, previously serving as acting director, secured confirmation in a 51-47 vote. She replaces withdrawn nominee Dave Weldon, whose bid faltered due to insufficient Senate support. Monarez now becomes the first CDC director formally confirmed by the Senate, a requirement enacted under a 2023 reform law passed after widespread failures exposed during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Her confirmation comes amid an ongoing overhaul of the CDC, spearheaded by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., and paired with Trump’s proposal to slash the agency’s bloated budget by more than 40%.
The move reflects deep public and congressional frustration with the CDC’s credibility, which cratered during the pandemic due to erratic, politically charged guidance that many now say lacked any scientific justification. Monarez takes over a deeply damaged institution under orders to reform or face further downsizing.
According to a damning 557-page report from the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic, the CDC issued its now-infamous six-foot social distancing rule in March 2020 without any scientific trials or evidence to support the measure. The guidance persisted unaltered for over two years — a decision the report blasts as arbitrary and harmful.
“There were no scientific trials or studies conducted before this policy was implemented,” the report stated. “More importantly, there appears to be no acceptance of responsibility. That is an unacceptable answer from public health leadership.”
The agency also came under fire for its mask mandates and school closure policies. The CDC based its universal masking guidance on 15 deeply flawed studies — none of which were randomized controlled trials, the gold standard for scientific reliability. The result: years of forced masking in schools, public spaces, and transportation systems, despite growing evidence of negligible benefit.
The report points out that COVID infection rates remained largely identical between states with mask mandates and those without, suggesting the CDC ignored real-world outcomes to fit a predetermined narrative. Even the World Health Organization took a more measured approach, discouraging routine masking for children under 11 and explicitly warning about the psychological and developmental damage caused by masking very young children.
“The CDC caused quantifiable harm to American children,” the House report concluded, adding that “the future consequences of these types of draconian policies are not yet known.”
The Trump administration has made clear that business-as-usual at the CDC is over. With Monarez now officially installed, she faces intense pressure not only to lead reform, but to rebuild public trust in an agency many now associate more with partisan politics than with scientific integrity.
White House officials say the goal is not just budget reduction, but a top-down restructuring of a bureaucracy that lost sight of its mission.
“She’s going to be held to the highest standard,” one senior administration source said. “There is zero tolerance moving forward for politicized science or bureaucratic arrogance. We need accountability, transparency, and reform.”
The CDC’s days of unchecked authority may be coming to an end. Under President Trump and a new slate of leadership at HHS and DOJ, the era of unverified health edicts and data manipulation is rapidly being replaced by scrutiny, oversight, and a renewed focus on the facts.
The post Senate Confirms Trump’s Pick To Head CDC As Agency Battles Criticism Over Pandemic Response appeared first on Real News Now.
About Author
