Last week saw 11 prominent lawmakers from New York detained by the Homeland Security police; their offense was demanding transparency and access to an obscured immigrant detention center located in Lower Manhattan. These arrests, which occurred at 26 Federal Plaza, took place following a standoff of about 60 minutes, where the elected representatives adamantly held their ground outside the detention center. They vehemently voiced their demands, staged protests in the hallway, and resorted to sitting down in an expression of nonviolent resistance, their voices resonating with chants and songs; soon after, they were apprehended with zip ties. Brad Lander, the city’s Comptroller, was among those arrested, including Senators Jabari Brisport, Gustavo Rivera, Julia Salazar and Assembly members Robert Carroll, Emily Gallagher, Jessica Gonzalez Rojas, Marcela Mitaynes, Steve Raga, Tony Simone, and Claire Valdez.
According to an announcement from the Homeland Security Department, over 70 individuals were taken into custody at the site, with the aforementioned lawmakers in the tally. The group consisted of advocates for immigrants’ rights, and religious leaders; they were protesting by obstructing the movement of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) vehicles shuttling detainees into and out of the facility. This detention facility’s existence at 26 Federal Plaza, a federal building that houses offices for DHS and the FBI as well as a primary immigration court in NYC, has been consistently denied by the agency.
However, in a revealing turn of events this past July, videos brought to light by the New York Immigration Coalition gave credence to accounts suggesting that inmates were being held in dismal conditions at the facility. The revealing footage showed about two dozen men cramped in a poorly lit room bereft of beds. Disturbingly, some were even showcased sleeping on the cold floor, with nothing more than aluminum emergency blankets for warmth. The only ‘privacy’ the facility provided was in the form of a short wall dividing living quarters from two toilets.
An inmate interviewed covertly on these recordings illuminated the grim reality, saying, ‘They haven’t provided us with food or medicine. We’re freezing. Some people have been holed up here for as long as two weeks. All we’re doing is waiting.’ Furthering the scrutiny of the facility, NYC’s public advocate Jumaane Williams articulated passionate arguments for protesting the detention center. Williams, who actively participated in blocking the site’s entrance, expressed, ‘I think it’s clear to all that everything going on behind us isn’t just illegal – it’s inhumane, and it has nothing to do with public safety.’
He persisted, emphasizing that privileged members of society should utilize their status to safeguard those who are more marginalized. Following these protests, the DHS issued a statement. According to their spokesperson, the detainees were guilty of either possessing a firearm, storing fentanyl, or being linked to gang activities. However, no supporting evidence was provided for these charges, nor were any detainees linked to these accusations identified.
A review of the latest immigration figures points out that around 71% of the ICE inmates have no criminal conviction. Moreover, the majority of those with criminal records have merely committed petty offenses. From data recorded in the month of June, it was clear that only a measly 7% of those detained had been convicted of violent crimes. Yet, the spokesperson for DHS chose to put the blame on the protesting citizens for causing the ‘chaos’ at the location which led to the arrest of 71 demonstrators.
New York City, which is recognized as a ‘sanctuary city,’ upholds laws that prohibit local agencies, including the New York Police Department, from cooperating with federal immigration enforcement. This exclusive cooperation only extends to rare cases where the person ICE seeks to detain has been convicted of a horrendous crime, and is accompanied by ICE presenting a judicial warrant. However, the city’s newly elected Mayor Eric Adams has faced a lawsuit and increasing pressure to modify this policy and foster greater collaboration with federal forces.
This incident came amidst a noticeable increase in ICE arrests and detentions throughout New York state, breaking previous records. Protestors pointed out that the state legislature has been largely passive in curbing this serious issue. A key demand voiced by the protestors was for the passing of the New York For All Act. This law would restrict the state agencies’ capability to collaborate with ICE and other federal enforcement.
Additionally, protestors implored the city council to pass the NYC Trust Act. Such a legal provision would make it possible by law for individuals to sue the NYPD or the city’s Department of Corrections for wrongful collaboration with ICE, contravening the city’s sanctuary laws. Speaking to the media after her arrest outside the plaza was Tiffany Cabán, a member of the city council. She stated, ‘We need to remove ICE from New York. Everyone detained in Federal Plaza must be set free. This is a humanitarian crisis. They are undergoing torment. We must enact laws on both state and city levels to ensure we maintain our status as a sanctuary city.’
This outcry of lawmakers, activists, and concerned citizens in New York sheds light on the alarming state of immigrant detention centers that remains a gray area shrouded in secrecy for most people. Accountability, transparency, and the upholding of basic human rights are values that stand at the bedrock of a fair and democratic society. The circumstances, as seen in this incident, not only question the status quo but importantly also underscore the need for systemic changes in how we view immigration policy, its regulation, and implementation. Persistent non-transparency in such grave matters erodes public trust and undermines the very values we uphold as a society.
There’s an important takeaway from these events: fostering transparent dialogue about our immigration policies can be the starting point for meaningful change. The inhumane conditions at the detention center, as described by the detainees and supported by the video evidence, demand immediate attention. As shown by the protests, the situation reaches far beyond political clashes – it deeply concerns matters of human rights and dignity. In a city known for its diversity and inclusive values, such blatant abuses of basic human rights should not go overlooked.
The unfolding scenario also throws light on the complexity of the sanctuary city policy in New York. Ngislaborative efforts between local law enforcement and federal agencies should aim to secure the welfare of immigrants rather than vilify or penalize them. Such blatant abuse of power amplifies the city’s urgent need for revisiting its policies regarding ICE’s operations and the care of immigrants in custody.
The scene at Federal Plaza is a powerful testament cultivating a social responsibility to one another. In the face of adversity, lawmakers, religious figures, and citizens stood in unity, expressing a profound commitment to uphold justice and equanimity. The resonance of their united voice for justice speaks to the urgency of the issue, calling for immediate tangible changes to the system dealing with immigration.
Lastly, the exercise of peaceful protest in the face of grave injustice is a reminder of the power citizens hold. Through unity, they amplified the leers of those caught in a grim situation, ignored and sidelined by existing systems. This inspiring display of solidarity and resistance has displayed the ugly truth behind the obscured detention center, raising vital questions about the transparency and humaneness in the immigration process.
The struggle to ensure the integrity and dignity of every individual in New York, from city official to immigrant, remains an ongoing battle. But it’s moments like these that define the trajectory towards a more inclusive and equitable society. The united stand against the secretive and mismanaged detention center paves the way for a more open and accountable handling of immigrant affairs, a move that should be non-negotiable in a city that prides itself as a sanctuary city.
The post New York Lawmakers Arrested for Protesting Immigrant Detention Center Conditions appeared first on Real News Now.
About Author
