President Joe Biden’s 2024 Thanksgiving proclamation has sparked controversy for omitting references to “Almighty God” or “Divine Providence,” marking a notable departure from historical traditions. Critics argue that the absence reflects an ongoing trend of secularizing national holidays, distancing them from their religious and historical roots.
A Shift from Historical Precedent
Thanksgiving proclamations in the past, dating back to President Abraham Lincoln, have traditionally included explicit acknowledgments of God. Lincoln’s 1863 proclamation famously urged Americans to give thanks to “our beneficent Father who dwelleth in the Heavens,” tying the holiday’s purpose to gratitude for divine blessings.
In contrast, Biden’s proclamation focused on expressing gratitude to various groups, including service members, first responders, public servants, and healthcare workers. While his message emphasized unity and collective resilience, it avoided religious language or mentions of a higher power.
Public and Political Reactions
The omission has drawn sharp criticism from some religious leaders and conservative commentators, who see it as part of a broader trend toward diminishing the role of faith in public life. Critics argue that Thanksgiving, a holiday deeply rooted in expressions of gratitude to God, is losing its spiritual significance in favor of secular messaging.
Supporters of the proclamation, however, have defended the decision, suggesting that the focus on inclusivity and appreciation for all Americans aligns with modern values.
Broader Implications
The controversy reflects broader cultural debates about the role of religion in public institutions and national traditions. As society becomes increasingly diverse, questions about how to balance historical religious elements with secular inclusivity have become more prominent.
For many, Thanksgiving remains a deeply personal holiday, celebrated with family and friends, where the expression of gratitude often includes individual faith practices. Biden’s proclamation, while avoiding overt religious references, still encouraged Americans to come together and reflect on shared values.
Looking Ahead
As national discussions around faith and public policy continue, debates like this highlight the evolving nature of American traditions and the tension between preserving historical roots and adapting to contemporary societal changes. Whether future proclamations will return to traditional language or continue in a secular direction remains to be seen.
Biden’s Thanksgiving Proclamation Criticized for Omitting References to God appeared first on Real News Now.
About Author
