Lawful immigrants such as a Columbia University activist holding a green card, a Georgetown University scholar on a student visa, and a Brown University kidney transplant expert on a work permit, are amongst those who recently found themselves in the grasp of immigration authorities or denied access to the U.S. despite legitimate authorization to be here. This phenomenon has perplexed many since President Donald Trump has publicly expressed his support for legal immigration and his administration has reassured the people that their aim for mass deportations is primarily on individuals who have committed heinous crimes.
In an intriguing warp of events, the deportations that have gained substantial public attention seem to be focused on the people who hold the legal right to reside in the U.S. While it is not entirely unusual for visa holders and green card residents to face deportations under different presidencies, the tactics enacted by Trump’s administration are considered extraordinary. As mentioned by Matthew Boaz, an immigration law professor at the University of Kentucky, the administration is bypassing conventional protocols and taking advantage of obscure immigration law passages with the aim of deporting people they choose, ideally with minimum due process.
One of the high-profile cases involves Mahmoud Khalil, a graduate of Columbia University and a pro-Palestinian activist, who was detained and threatened with deportation under a regulation established during the Cold War era. The law allows the secretary of state to label a foreign national’s presence or activities as a threat to U.S. foreign policy interests, thereby making them liable for deportation. However, as of yet, no evidence has been furnished to illustrate how Khalil’s actions have endangered these interests.
In another instance pertaining again to Columbia University and the pro-Palestine movement, this Cold War-era regulation is brought to light once more as a different student faces potential detention and deportation. Luckily for the student, an interim injunction against this action was granted by a federal judge, providing a temporary shield.
Within the parameters of immigration law, authorities are required to present sound evidence when seeking to deport an individual holding a visa or a green card. In a scenario where a person enjoys lawful permanent residency, also known as green card status, they have the privilege to defend their case in a courtroom before any decisions about deportation are made. It’s important to note that the power to revoke a green card lies solely in the hands of an immigration judge.
There’s a variety of reasons that can make a green card holder susceptible to deportation, some of them being severe criminal convictions like rape, murder, or drug trafficking. The law also permits the expulsion of permanent residents who are discovered to have committed immigration fraud.
In the case concerning Mahmoud Khalil, the government puts forth the argument that he did not disclose his involvement with the United Nations agency for Palestine refugees, UNRWA, and other international organizations. After his apprehension, Khalil’s legal team moved to file a petition, claiming that his detention by ICE is a First Amendment violation as it is ‘based on his speech.’ Drug-related convictions could also serve as grounds for deportation.
Visa holders within the U.S., whether they are tourists, students, or workers, are also given notices to appear in the event the government believes they are deportable. Reasons for considering the deportation of a visa holder could range from crime and fraud, exceeding the terms of their visa, to working without authorization. Visa holders, much like legal permanent residents, are entitled to due process, and the burden of proof lies with the government.
One such case involves Badar Khan Suri, a graduate student at Georgetown University who teaches while being here on a student visa. He currently awaits the outcome of immigration proceedings after being detained by immigration authorities. On another note, visa holders can also be denied entry at the U.S. border or airport since having a visa does not automatically guarantee entry into the U.S.
Customs and Border Protection officers wield the authority to either grant or deny entry to individuals. Accordingly, they possess the power to admit individuals or refuse their entry based on their own judgement. This led to the unfortunate incident where Rasha Alawieh, a kidney transplant specialist holding a work visa, was denied entry at an airport after officers discovered images of Hezbollah members on her phone. Alawieh was subsequently deported before the immigration officers could receive a judge’s order, stating otherwise.
The French government recently reported that a scientist, one of its own citizens, was denied entry to the U.S. due to ‘personal opinion’ about the Trump administration’s science policies expressed in messages found on his phone. It becomes clear that the rights and freedoms of individuals already residing within the U.S. are protected by the constitution. No taskforce, including immigration agents, has the right to enter people’s homes unless equipped with a warrant, officially signed by a judge.
This reassures residents that, to obtain a judicial warrant, immigration officers must furnish substantial ‘evidence of a crime’ in front of a judge, ensuring a fair process. However, it should be noted that rights may fluctuate in locations like airports where laws and procedures often differ.
Ultimately, individuals with legal immigration status are not invulnerable to immigration enforcement actions in the United States. Actions by immigration authorities during the Trump administration illustrated this with several high-profile cases. These cases and the experiences of these individuals raised questions about the due process rights of visa and green card holders and the ways immigration law and enforcement can impact those with legitimate residency or visitation rights.
The post Legal immigrants Face Deportation Despite Promises from Trump Administration appeared first on Real News Now.
About Author
