Although guacamole has managed to navigate around the imposition of tariffs for the time being, salsa may face a bumpier route. Despite the decision from President Trump to hold off on the threatened levies on Mexican avocados, the administration is contemplating imposing almost 21% duty on freshly imported Mexican tomatoes as of July 14th. This form of duty, much like a tariff, consists of a tax on imports which would affect the annual import of 4 billion pounds of tomatoes from Mexico. Supporters of this tax hope it would bolster the shrinking tomato industry in the U.S. and promote locally grown produce consumption.
Mexican tomatoes have flooded the U.S. market, accounting for almost 70% of the total share; this starkly contrasts the previous 30% share from twenty years ago. Robert Guenther raises a poignant concern: ‘Without leveling the playing field in terms of equitable pricing, the domestic industry for fresh tomatoes will be non-existent in the not-so-distant future.’ The states producing the most tomatoes in the U.S. are Florida and California. However, California’s yield predominantly finds its way into various products such as sauces.
Detractors of this proposed duty fear that this will cause a surge in the cost of fresh tomatoes for U.S. consumers. The implications for NatureSweet, a company that cultivates tomatoes in both Mexico and the U.S., are potentially significant. This firm would face a monthly multi-million dollar charge in duties should this decision come into effect. ‘While we will constantly seek out methods to optimize our operations, the fundamental truth is that we are constantly endeavoring to run a highly efficient business as is,’ remarks Skip Hulett, the company’s chief legal officer.
According to Hulett, ‘Produce isn’t a high-margin industry. We’re in the process of determining how much of the cost we could bear, but inevitably, some of these added costs will have to be transferred to the consumer.’ Tim Richards, professor at Arizona State University, predicts that if the tax is implemented, there will be an approximately 10.5% increase in the retail price of tomatoes in the U.S.
Last month, Mexico’s government expressed optimism about its ability to negotiate on this issue. If, however, the tomato tax is imposed, Claudia Sheinbaum, Mexico’s President, signals the likelihood of Mexico counteracting by imposing duties on chicken and pork legs, both high volume imports from the U.S.
The battle over tomatoes between the two countries is not new. The origins can be tracked back to 1996, when the U.S. Department of Commerce began an inquiry into allegations of Mexico exporting tomatoes to the U.S. at artificially suppressed prices, known as dumping. A suspensive condition placed on the investigation required Mexico to adhere to certain terms, one of which included selling its tomatoes at a minimum price.
Following this, the agreement underwent sporadic reviews. However, each time both parties managed to reach an agreement, which averted the need for tariffs. However, more recently, the Commerce Department announced they would be retracting their involvement in the agreement. It cited being ‘inundated with complaints’ from U.S. growers calling for better safeguarding measures against Mexican tomato imports.
Guenther, from the Florida Tomato Exchange, argues that loopholes still exist. Even though Mexican exporters are expected to adhere to a minimum price requirement, authorities spot check shipments, hence Mexican sellers can circumvent this policy. On a broader scale, Guenther articulates that U.S.’s tomato industry suffers from Mexico’s lower production costs: unlike in the U.S., Mexican land, labor, and materials like seeds and fertilizer are cheaper.
Tomatoes, as Guenther argues, are a labor-intensive crop. Most of the U.S. industry relies heavily on immigrant labor through the H-2A visa program. The minimum wage defined by this program was on average $16.98 per hour last year, a figure that has escalated because of the scarcity of labor. On the other hand, estimates show that laborers on Mexican farms receive around a tenth of the U.S. rate.
The advantage of cheaper cost of producing tomatoes in Mexico is acknowledged by NatureSweet, but they stress that climate plays a vital role as well. According to the company, their greenhouses in Mexico can operate all year round without any need for lighting, heating, or cooling systems. ‘Certain industries can be moved, but climate agriculture isn’t one of them,’ Hulett pointed out.
Lance Jungmeyer, the president of the Fresh Produce Association of the Americas, echoes this by stating that Florida falls short in producing the vine-ripened tomatoes that are increasingly beloved by American consumers. Instead, Florida picks its tomatoes while they’re still green and then ferries them to warehouses for ripening. ‘Florida isn’t cultivating the types of specialty tomatoes that are trending, yet they want protection,’ asserts Jungmeyer. ‘Their market share is dwindling as a result of their own decisions.’
However, Guenther begs to differ, ‘I would assert that a Florida-grown tomato would fare quite well in a taste comparison with a Mexican-grown one.’ Adrian Burciaga, co-owner of Don Artemio, a Texas-based restaurant, doesn’t entertain the notion of switching to a U.S. provider. He likens it to choosing a good wine; for a fine Cabernet Sauvignon, he chooses Napa, California, and for a tomato that carries nostalgic flavors of his youth, he opts for Mexico.
Burciaga’s restaurant utilizes between 300 to 400 pounds of Roma tomatoes from Mexico each week. To date, he equates to $19 for every 25-pound crate of tomatoes. Though the extra expense is unwelcome, Burciaga feels he has limited options. Burciaga laments that the potential tomato tax, alongside the potential for Trump to implement a waiting 25% tariff on numerous other Mexican products, overturns the stability needed for a smaller-scale establishment. ‘The unpredictability is concerning. A small or medium restaurant anticipates things in advance. In half a year, things will increase, so we’re able to adjust,’ he stated. ‘But these last-minute tariff changes disrupt our ability to plan and subsequently react.’
The post Potential Threat to Salsa: A 21% Duty on Imported Mexican Tomatoes appeared first on Real News Now.
About Author
