During President Donald Trump’s tenure, a startling directive was passed down which involved sharing personal data, encompassing immigration status, of millions of Medicaid users with the deportation officials. This action was feared could facilitate the tracking and thus, the deportation of these individuals as part of his aggressive immigration policy. An internal memo alongside a series of emails disclose the unsuccessful attempts by Medicaid officials to prevent this data dispatch on ethical and legal grounds. Despite the outcry, two premier consultants to Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. instructed that the dataset be delivered to the Department of Homeland Security.
The employees at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services were given less than an hour on a Tuesday to implement this decision. The data released pertained to residents of California, Illinois, Washington state, and Washington D.C. Notably, these regions permit non-US citizens to enlist in Medicaid schemes that cover their healthcare expenses through state taxpayer dollars exclusively. Interestingly, the data handover coincided with the implementation of expansive enforcement operations in Southern California by the Trump administration.
Expert commentators suggest that this data, apart from aiding authorities in locating migrants, could potentially be used to obstruct the immigration prospects of those seeking permanent residency, green cards, or citizenship. This obstruction would apply especially to those who had at any point utilized Medicaid benefits funded by the federal government. In response to this unsettling development, California’s Governor Gavin Newsom’s office voiced its concerns through a statement about the alarming ways in which deportation authorities might apply this data.
The apprehension swelled particularly because these operations were being conducted with the support of the National Guard troops and Marines in Los Angeles. A spokesperson for U.S. Health and Human Services, however, stated that the sharing of this private information was within legal bounds. An associated official from DHS asserted that Trump had committed to safeguarding Medicaid for those rightfully eligible.
Enforcing this commitment, after unruly aliens, both CMS, and DHS initiated an exploratory project to ensure that no illegal aliens were availing Medicaid benefits intended for law-abiding Americans. Evidently, this initiative signifies a larger effort by the Trump administration to empower the DHS with comprehensive data about migrants.
In the later part of the previous month, CMS had announced its decision to investigate certain state’s Medicaid users to ascertain that no federal resources had been channeled towards insuring individuals with unsatisfactory immigration status. In alignment with this review, California, Washington, and Illinois provided details regarding non-US individuals enrolled in their state’s Medicaid system.
Officials from the CMS had passionately resisted this data sharing demand from Homeland Security on the grounds that it might breach federal laws. These laws included the historic Social Security Act along with the Privacy Act of 1974. They maintained that divulging information about Medicaid applicants or recipients to DHS would be transgressing a long-standing policy.
However, their legal rationale did not carry much weight with the Trump appointees stationed at HHS, which supervises the Medicaid agency. Former government personnel commented that this unprecedented move was extraordinary since CMS which had access to personal health data of almost half the country generally refrained from divulging such sensitive information to other departments.
Regulations mandate that every state must provide emergency Medicaid services to all non-US individuals. This extends even to those who are legally present but are still within the five-year waiting period to apply for Medicaid. Additionally, seven states including the District let immigrants residing illegally in the country to fully enroll in their state’s Medicaid program.
These innovative programs were instituted during the previous administration. Next to the enactment, it was communicated that these governments would not invoice the federal government for the healthcare costs incurred by these immigrant groups. Despite the affirmative commitments made, the present administration has voiced skepticism about such promises.
The post Scandalous Data Sharing Act: The Failing Stance of Biden-Harris appeared first on Real News Now.
About Author
