The United States Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) contentious demand pertaining to the sharing of confidential information of recipients of federal food aid is currently at a standstill. An official from the USDA disclosed in judicial documents that the collection process of personal data from beneficiaries of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) hasn’t commenced as a result of ongoing legal proceedings, the basis of which is an allegation stating that the directive breaches federal privacy statutes.
In the preceding month, the USDA commissioned states to provide data of individuals who had sought or were beneficiaries of SNAP in the past half-decade. This information encompassed specifics such as the recipients’ full names, dates of birth, Social Security identifiers, and physical addresses. The states were advised to relay this data via their respective third-party contractors in charge of executing electronic fiscal transactions.
The directive arose from an executive order issued on March 20, which advocated for federal bodies to have unrestricted access to data derived from state schemes that were the recipients of federal grants, extending to third-party databases. This was part of the Department of Government Efficiency’s efforts which include consolidating and gathering data from different federal bodies for an array of purposes including, but not limited to immigration enforcement.
Several states including Iowa and Ohio expressed their readiness to comply with the data request posited by the USDA. However, a group comprising of SNAP beneficiaries and organizations involved with issues pertaining to hunger, privacy, and educational advocacy proceeded to sue the USDA in federal court. Their argument was centered on the unlawfulness of the data request and its failure to adhere to established data gathering protocols.
In response to this legal action, the USDA representative conveyed that the data requisition was currently in a state of suspension, further indicating that all proper legal stipulations connected to data protection and management would be satisfied prior to the resumption of data gathering activities. The exact timeline when this communication was made to the payment processors remains uncertain.
The revelation followed that upon the USDA’s request, an email thread was triggered by a payment processing firm to its partner states. This email highlighted the USDA’s endeavor to collect data and requested written consent for the same. As things stand, no data has been conveyed to the USDA as of now.
Adding another dimension to the unfolding situation, it was included in the revelations that the USDA commenced efforts to conform to the Privacy Act’s mandate to file notice and elicit public opinion regarding the new data collection measures. This filing, referred to as a Systems of Record Notice (SORN), would serve to justify the intent behind the data gathering and afford opportunity for public scrutiny and input.
For the parties engaged in the legal proceedings against the USDA, this is a momentary triumph; the USDA has conceded to the applicability of federal privacy laws to the process of data collection. Moreover, the protection of data is still ensured as the information continues to reside with the states and their contracted third parties.
Every month, the SNAP program benefits more than 40 million people, adding further weight to the implications and consequences of the USDA’s attempts at data access. The ultimate result of these proceedings could have significant implications on the future handling of beneficiary data in federally funded programs.
The post USDA’s Controversial Data Gathering Suspended Amid Legal Challenges appeared first on Real News Now.
About Author
