Prominent sports commentator Stephen A. Smith stirred the emotions of many people in Memphis when he aired his views about safety in the city on ESPN’s “First Take” on the 17th of June. His remarks seemed to echo in every corner of Memphis, generating a considerable backlash. Smith, a renowned voice in American sports, made potent remarks regarding public safety issues in the city. He lauded Memphis as a city with exceptional sports enthusiasm and remarkable residents.
However, he also remarked on an ‘element’ of the city, possibly accruing to a sense of unsafety among certain NBA players such as Jimmy Butler. According to him, these players did not think of Memphis as the safest place. He added that he had heard such concerns directly from the players. His comments were aimed at the local authorities in Memphis, whom he urged to tackle the underlying issues.
Smith seemed to suggest that the perceived lack of safety could potentially deter NBA players from the city. He felt the need to articulate these concerns, as they had been confided in him directly by several players. His fiery commentary sparked a significant reaction, causing ripples throughout the sports community and beyond.
One of the individuals who reacted swiftly was the Memphis Grizzlies star Ja Morant. Morant made sure to respond to Smith’s controversial views through a series of posts on various social media platforms. The heavily discussed topic was not restricted to social media but also brought up at a locally held ‘Tigers On Tour’ event.
The ‘Tigers on Tour’ event, curated for fans at The Owners Box in Lakeland, had senior sports coaches and administrators from the University of Memphis in attendance. All the coaches, including Penny Hardaway of men’s basketball, Ryan Silverfield from football, Brooks Monaghan from women’s soccer, and Richard Mulrooney from men’s soccer, felt the need to comment on the issue. During the question and answer segment, this topic stood out and stirred a heated conversation among the crowd.
Post-event interviews also spotlighted the same issue. Ryan Silverfield made an apt observation that ‘crime doesn’t have a zip code’. Silverfield placed on record his feeling of safety in Memphis. He highlighted that he had lived in Memphis for a decade and was raising his two daughters there, indicating that the city offers ample opportunities for growth.
Brooks Monaghan, native to Memphis and a seasoned coach with the Tigers for 25 years (coincidentally, the same duration of the Grizzlies’ tenure in Memphis), firmly addressed the situation. He expressed frustration about the recurrent stereotype of their city, especially among outsiders. Although he admitted not everything was perfect in the city, he stressed that issues happen everywhere.
Monaghan continued to break down these misconceptions through his experiences coaching women. He also pointed out how the overall crime perception doesn’t change for other cities even possessing the same issues, making a reference to Nashville. He mused upon the differential view, stating that just as he felt comfortable with his children attending school in Memphis, others should as well.
Subsequently, Paul Young, the Mayor of Memphis, chose to respond to the situation via social media as well. His statement was a balanced mix of reaction and invitation. Initially, Mayor Young presented some data by stating that there was a significant decline in crime rates in the years 2024 and 2025.
Then, Mayor Young warmly invited anyone, including Jimmy Butler or Stephen Smith, to visit the city and see the reality for themselves. He communicated a spirit of defiance and resilience, urging everyone not to underestimate Memphis, a city that never shies away from challenges.
In his closing remarks, Mayor Young commended the people of Memphis and Ja Morant particularly for getting involved in the discussion. His appreciation for Morant’s explicit support for the city was clear. He praised Morant, stating that his public stand was an embodiment of the true spirit of Memphis.
The mayor expressed that Morant’s influential stance validated his strong ties with the city. Beyond his undeniable talent, Young believed that it was Morant’s heartfelt pride in his city that effectively highlighted his essence as a true Memphian.
In conclusion, although Smith’s comment on the perceived safety of Memphis created a stir, it sparked a vibrant discussion among the local community leaders and sports figures. It brought to light the city’s spirit of resilience and its endeavors to ensure safety and growth. Moreover, it underpinned the sense of pride that figures like Morant have in their city, perhaps suggesting that the heart of Memphis is strong, and its citizens are ready to rise to challenges.
The post Sports Commentator Ignites Safety Debate in Memphis appeared first on Real News Now.
About Author
